How Italian Food Became as American as Apple Pie

In his new book, “How Italian Food Conquered the World,” John F. Mariani, food-and-wine correspondent for Esquire magazine, charts the rise of a cuisine through its cross-continental metamorphosis from provincial peasant dishes to becoming the edible ambassador of a diaspora that dominates both the high- and low-end of dining out.  Although Mariani’s title indicates a global perspective, the book’s singular focus is Italian food in America, and specifically, how that became Italian-American food, a separate species that still represents Italy and Italian culture throughout the world.

America has a culture and cuisine shaped in most part by its immigrants, and the massive wave of 5 million Italians who arrived between 1880 and 1910 brought with them ideas about food that would completely reshape the American dining landscape.  More than 80 percent of these immigrants were from the poor and rural south of Italy, from places like Sicily and Campagna where they knew little of restaurants but had a tradition of simple, hearty fare which they tried to keep up in their adopted country with the paltry ingredients that were available to them.

Since 1860, when the idea of restaurants became popular in France, and for 100 years after, French cuisine defined dining out.  It was complicated and time-consuming, a sophisticated world of refinery that shaped people’s ideas about what dining out meant.  In this context, the small pizza shops and trattorias serving up Italian dishes of a few simple ingredients were considered mere peasant food, the food of poor immigrants.

After World War II, Italian cuisine began making inroads on American cuisine, through products like Chef Boyardee’s ubiquitous canned pastas, and through the rising popularity of Italian restaurants thanks to American travelers coming back from Italy.  For decades though, real Italian ingredients were still not available in the U.S.  Until the 1980’s, for example, it was impossible to get extra virgin olive oil in America.

Then, the International Olive Oil Council started sponsoring and promoting research about the healthy “Mediterranean diet.”  This coincided with the Slow Food movement emerging from Turin, emphasizing the European style artisanal approach to crafting food products.  Finally, olive oil was distributed in the U.S. and Italian food became more authentic, something that, as Mariani says, is recognizable to Italians themselves as their own cuisine.

Now, the regional and micro-regional distinctions in Italian cooking are well-known to Americans and olive oil is available in every supermarket.  The idea of simple, authentic Italian food, prepared with ingredients of the highest integrity, has become the new standard of dining out in America, one that’s so widespread, it’s hard to imagine that there was a time not so long ago when popular magazines had to explain how to eat a pizza.

Click Here to buy the book from Amazon.

More articles on: , ,

This article was last updated January 5, 2015 - 8:19 AM (GMT-5)

  • Jerry

    Over Easter dinner family members were discussing the hosts success at replicating Grandma’s mustard, a specialty served in the family restaurant in the 1950’s. The passed down recipe contained olive oil, but so,me at the table said that could not be correct, because olive oil was not even available in the U.S. at that time. And – by the way – the family was not Italian. MY QUESTION: When did olive oil first come into common use in American kitchens?

  • christie

    Olive oil was here in 1950, extra virgin was not here perhaps. But progresso brand olive oil was very very close to extra virgin , and before it was the rage (EVOO) we used that quite a bit. As a kid I hated salad out of my house,or at from non- Eyetalian homes because they used Wesson (yeck) and white vinegar.

    Now Wesson and crisco and others are fine for most cooking saute , but for salads and as a finish and as a drizzle for pizza well, no, they all suck. When I make salads I someties mix regular olive oil with extra virgin to back down the olive taste, to allow more of other tastes come through or for non EVOO lovers. I used to use Sunflower oil a lot, but it no longer available from Wesson and I miss it. The stuff from Turkey is horrid, but available.

    this is a great site, I wish they list results of the tests done and if there are current tests being done