Olive Oil’s Biggest Problem

Opinion & Commentary

By Virginia Brown Keyder, on March 17, 2013

“Although no revolutionary product is yet ready for supermarket shelves, executives of these companies are confident. ‘In a few decades, probably 75% of the food we eat will come from genetically engineered crops,’ says Edward T. Shonsey, who runs the U.S. seeds division of Novartis AG, a Swiss pharmaceutical and chemical concern that plans to embark on an agricultural-acquisition spree.”(1)

That was 1998. Two core patents later(2), and free-riding on a highly successful campaign by olive oil producers to inform the world of the health benefits of olive oil, and in particular of oleic acid, Monsanto is poised to launch a soybean oil that will be both cheaper than olive oil and mirror at least some of its major health effects.

Based on Round-Up-Ready soybeans (a fact not likely to be used in its advertising campaigns), this may prove to be the public relations coup of the century for Monsanto, who may at last claim to be producing something that is good for humans.

Of course, the high priests of olive oil and their flocks will not be swayed – they will continue to extol the bitter taste of fine oils regardless. But for the mass markets of new devotees from Patagonia to Beijing, many of whom are drawn to olive oil’s health benefits rather than the taste, and for the already olive-disenfranchised of the Mediterranean region increasingly receptive to other options for healthy fats, Monsanto’s pitch may well have sticking power.

For the extra virgin olive oil industry, this comes at a bad time. Supplies are down due to weather conditions, particularly in Spain, the world’s largest producer, and this means prices are up. The world is still mired in recession and shows no signs of recovering in the near future. This does not bode well for high-end, expensive-to-produce extra virgin oil, which is already being replaced by lower quality olive oils, blends and cheaper alternatives.

As if this were not bad enough, the industry is engaged in destructive infighting, with New World producers intent on bad-mouthing the European and North African oils to win market share at home and in new markets abroad. This is in spite of the fact that the past few years have seen a barrage of new EU laws aimed at quality assurance, and environmental and consumer protection.

This is not to belittle problems with European oils in the past, but with the USITC report on olive oil competition to come out in August (as mentioned in earlier articles – this is never for nothing), and the likely mud to be slung following in the US Farm Bill vs. the new EU Common Agricultural Policy (despite cuts voted through last week), the prospects look sadly lacking for the world extra virgin industry pulling together and recognizing the real danger of cheap soy bean oil dressed up to look healthy.

Where’s the International Olive Council in all of this? The intergovernmental organization is so trapped in old ways of doing business it could not even reach a quorum to pass its own budget, leaving it in a state of paralysis. It sat out a critical Codex meeting and its director, Jean-Louis Barjol, passed up an invitation from the organizers of next month’s New York International Olive Oil Competition to address an audience assembled for the first major olive oil event in the world’s biggest market — a seemingly good place and time to mend fences.

If anyone thinks Monsanto may not be able to pull this off, cast your eyes back to their success last year in convincing Californians (Californians!) they that don’t want to know what’s in their food, and forward to the probable passage next week of what has come to be called the Monsanto Protection Act(3) in the US Congress. Across the pond, the EU (at the level of the Commission as well as the European patent office) seems inexplicably (if you ignore the growing army of lobbyists) favorably disposed towards Monsanto and its ilk as well(4).

It’s not too late. This could be the brief moment in time when a united olive oil industry could work together to confront what may be its biggest rival, which has nothing to do with borders or countries of origin.

Do you have an opinion you’d like to share in an article? See our submission form and guidelines here.

More articles on: , , , ,

This article was last updated November 23, 2014 - 3:46 PM (GMT-5)

  • http://wp.me/Igbc Prattle On, Boyo

    Monsanto did not “convince” Californians they don’t want GMO labeling. With the help of a clerk in Fresno County, and the Secretary of State, Debra Bowen, shutting her eyes to shenanigans during the Prop 37 recount, Monsanto was able to quash GMO labeling. Read more about the corruption of the recount here >> http://t.co/wMNRINob

    • virginia

      As a true blood Californian (3rd generation Oakland-born), I’m glad to hear it. Still, it is an indication of the kind of power they wield. Thanks for yours.

  • Nancy Harmon Jenkiins

    Excellent summation of an unnecessarily complex situation. Everyone who loves olive oil should read this.

  • OliveChirper

    I don’t think this poses any particular threat to EVOO. Remember (or, if you didn’t know: be informed that) nearly all of the sunflower and safflower oil on supermarket shelves in N. America today is high-oleic varieties, which contain >75% oleic acid and were produced by conventional breeding and thus don’t have the taint in the minds of some people of genetic modification. If there were a threat — or, to the extent that there is a threat — it’s been with us for decades and is already baked into the cake.

  • filippo camerini

    Part of consumers all over the world demand non GMOs produce and products. Due to cross pollination (cross genetic pollution) Conventional and EU standard organic cannot share the same land with GMO. US farming is much more competitive for massive production of agriculture goods.
    These above accepted, it would be a mistake (also as the market strategy) for the EU (and EVOO producers and manufatures) to follow the US in the rush to GMOs

    • virginia

      A terrible mistake, but this is what the US is looking for in the EU/US trade agreement, in addition to cutting down the EU PDO/PGI regime. Europe really has to stay on its toes here, but this looks pretty difficult for it to do right now.

    • virginia

      Unfortunately, the EU has just drafted a new Regulation that would make GMO entry into the EU easier, while the proposed EU/US trade agreement would allow Monsanto to sue individual EU member states who reject GMOs. EU citizens need to be informed of the provisions of this agreement before the Commission carries it through.

  • Adam Kossioris Kouros Olive O

    I agree with the article on the point that the
    International Olive Council is not sufficiently active, and the current competition between the two major European olive oil producers for international market
    share and EU marketing funding has turned in to an opportunity for other competitors to emerge.
    Olive oil is a unique natural product; it is compressed directly from the fruit and it contains all its natural properties,in all its purity. Soy bean oil or any other seed oil, dressed up to look healthy will be no threat to olive oil. They are mechanically and chemically extracted, man- made products that in the process are made to look and taste oily. Olive oil has never and will never compete with other inferior products such as seed oils.Knowledge is fast spreading to the consumers and the trend is confirmed by the growing world consumption.
    Greece with its yearly 400.000 tons of Olive oil production and 82% of which is Extra Virgin of premium quality is advancing in the international arena. No
    obstacles will stop our initiative to place our superior oil in all the shelves of the major food stores of the world.

    Adam Kossioris
    Kouros Olive Oil Exporters

    • virginia

      I totally agree – I wouldn’t touch soybean oil with the proverbial ten-foot pool, but it is dangerous to be so sure that no one will be fooled. Monsanto and its partner in crime, the USDA (who declared GM soybeans beyond reproach years ago) is tooling up big time for this and there is little evidence that the growing Asian market cares about the taste we all love, when presented with cheaper oil claiming the same (I know, I know) health benefits. One must never be too sure the competition will fail.