World
The CBS News segment on ’60 Minutes’ exposed mafia involvement in Italian agriculture, particularly in the olive oil trade, leading to suspicions about the authenticity of the “Made in Italy” brand. The report featured interviews with Italian investigator Sergio Tirro and author Tom Mueller, who highlighted the prevalence of food crime in Italy, with up to 80% of olive oil labeled as “extra virgin” potentially being counterfeit.
The CBS News magazine ‘60 Minutes’ aired a segment on mafia involvement in Italian agriculture tonight, introducing millions of viewers to the shady underworld of the olive oil trade and casting a fresh pall of suspicion over the “Made in Italy” brand.
“Mafia copies of fine olive oil, wine and cheese have fueled an explosion of food crime in Italy,” said CBS News correspondent, Bill Whitaker.
It’s very difficult to say in any given case with olive oil exactly how many drops in a given bottle actually have Mafia blood on them.- Tom Mueller
In addition to a conversation with Italian investigator Sergio Tirro, whose team of 60 trained tasters are able to detect counterfeit olive oils “at first sip,” the report featured an interview with Tom Mueller, the author of the Extra Virginity exposé.
“You in many cases are getting lower grade olive oil that has been blended with some good extra virgin olive oil…you’re sometimes getting deodorized oil,” Mueller said. “They blend it with some oil that has some character to give it a little color, a little flavor…and they sell that as extra virgin. It’s illegal — it happens all the time.”
Before an estimated 12 million viewers who had just watched the Denver Broncos defeat the San Diego Chargers in a close late-season football game, Tirro demonstrated how easy it is to counterfeit extra virgin olive oil.
Taking a vial of colorless, odorless sunflower oil, he added a few drops of chlorophyll. “It becomes the color of olive oil,” Tirro said. It’s as simple as that.
Sicilian olive oil producer, Nicola Clemenza, is leading a 200-farmer uprising against mafia control in the region.
“On the day I started the consortium, they burned my car, they burned down part of my home and I was inside with my wife and my daughter,” Clemenza said.
Mueller said mafia control pervades the food supply in Italy, and described its impact on olive oil in the bleakest terms: “It’s very difficult to say in any given case with olive oil exactly how many drops in a given bottle actually have Mafia blood on them.“
See Also:Listen to an Interview with Tom Mueller on the On Olive Oil Podcast
When Whitaker asked how much of the olive oil labeled “extra virgin” that reaches Americans is really not extra virgin, Mueller responded, “75% to 80%, easily.”
CBS News shipped 3 bottles of olive oil found in an unnamed American supermarket to Tirro’s tasting panel: Only one was found to be extra virgin.
“They described one as lampante — the lowest quality olive oil. That brand happens to be one of the best-selling in America,” Whitaker said.
The top-selling brand in the United States is Bertolli, which is the subject of a high-profile fraud investigation and multiple class action lawsuits.
See the ’60 Minutes’ segment here.
More articles on: Made in Italy, olive oil adulteration, olive oil fraud
Nov. 20, 2024
Olive Oil Sommelier Program Returns to London
The Olive Oil Times Education Lab will return to Central London with its flagship five-day Sommelier program.
Aug. 7, 2024
One-Third of World Olive Oil Competition Entries Organic for the First Time
Organic extra virgin olive oils account for a growing share of submissions in the annual evaluation in New York.
May. 6, 2025
Producers in Spain Cap Strong Harvest with Quality Awards
Spain's olive industry thrived in 2025, producing 1.41 million metric tons and winning 93 awards at the NYIOOC World Olive Oil Competition.
May. 31, 2025
Italian Producers Extend Reign of Excellence at World Competition
Uncompromising farmers, millers and bottlers made Italy the most awarded country at the 2025 NYIOOC for the tenth consecutive year.
Oct. 13, 2024
S. Hemisphere Producers Reap Rewards of Challenging Harvest
Farmers, millers and bottlers from three continents combined to win 44 awards at the Southern Hemisphere edition of 2024 World Olive Oil Competition.
Sep. 18, 2024
Calabrian Cooperative Emphasizes Quality While Building Economies of Scale
Seventeen olive oil producers have joined to promote Carolea extra virgin olive oils while driving down farming and milling costs.
Jul. 23, 2024
Fustiness, Rancidity Are the Most Common Defects in World Competition Submissions
Defects prevent olive oil from qualifying as an extra virgin, while diminishing its taste and health benefits.
Mar. 18, 2025
French Supermarket Chain Recalls House Brand After Detecting Contaminant
Monoprix voluntarily recalled its 750-milliliter extra virgin olive oils after detecting mineral oil hydrocarbons that exceeded European safety standards.