Business
Cheese producers in France are once again protesting against Nutri-Score, the nutritional front-of-pack labeling (FOPL) system created by scientists in the country.
They fear that sales would be impacted negatively if the controversial food rating system is made mandatory by the European Commission. Nutri-Score ratings are currently voluntary in France.
The new offensive against Nutri-Score comes on the heels of the recent update to the algorithm used to determine ratings.
See Also:French Draft Bill to Exclude PDO and PGI Products From Nutri-ScoreThe National Council of PDO-Certified Specialties (CNAOL) asked the French government to ensure that cheese makers would be considered in the update.
However, it did not help the ratings of most cheeses, including those with a Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) certification, which is reserved for traditional food specialties. Some ratings were even revised downward due to fat and salt contents penalized by Nutri-Score.
“It’s disastrous,” council chairman Hubert Dubien said. “The modifications have made nothing better. It’s even worse for some [cheeses].”
Cheese producers have criticized the algorithm update, arguing their traditionally-produced products should not receive the same rating as processed foods, including frozen pizzas and vanilla ice cream.
Nutri-Score is a traffic-light-style FOPL that uses a combination of five coordinated colors and letters to rate how healthy a packaged food item is based on its fat, sugar, salt and calorie content per 100-gram or milliliter serving. The “Green A” indicates the healthiest option, and “Red E” denotes the least healthy.
The creators and backers of Nutri-Score said the rating system is meant to help consumers make choices among products in the same category, such as edible oils, and is not meant for cross-comparisons.
In response to the Nutri-Score ratings, the council released a document demonstrating the cultural qualities of PDO cheese production.
The document showed that nearly 78 percent of PDO cheeses are made from raw milk, meaning the milk is not heated above 40 ºC before production. They also stated that 28 of 46 PDO kinds of cheese are exclusively made with raw milk.
Producing cheese with raw milk preserves its micro-organisms, which influences the final taste of the cheese. The council argued that these micro-organisms are the essence of local cheese traditions.
Meanwhile, in Italy, a member of the previous government, which lost power in the September elections, said Nutri-Score is unlikely to be adopted by the European Union as its mandatory FOPL.
Stefano Patuanelli, the former agriculture minister, told Il Sole 24 Ore that “when we were put in charge [of the ministry], the fight against Nutri-Score seemed without hope. Instead, we can say that if the game has ended, it has ended for the traffic-light labeling system.”
Italy has long been home to some of Nutri-Score’s most outspoken critics, with many rallying behind the rival Nutrinform Battery FOPL.
According to Patuanelli, the European health commission’s general direction has already said that a traffic light FOPL does not provide enough information to consumers.
However, the European Food Safety Agency and Joint Research Center found that FOPLs like Nutri-Score might influence consumers to make healthier choices.
The European Commission said it will adopt a mandatory pan-European FOPL before March 2023.
More articles on: France, Nutri-Score, Protected Designation of Origin
Feb. 19, 2024
How One Producer Deals with Rising Volumes and A Shorter Harvest in France
In the South of France, the producer behind Mas des Bories manages a bumper harvest and a shorter window to mill.
Feb. 20, 2024
New Research Rekindles Debate on Nutri-Score’s Effectiveness
The OECD found Nutri-Score could save money on healthcare. Dutch researchers questioned the integrity of studies supporting the labeling system.
Jun. 1, 2023
Consumer Group in France Finds Olive Oils Contaminated with Hydrocarbons
Test results published by the National Consumer Institute, found that 23 of 24 olive oils had traces of plasticizer and hydrocarbon contamination.
May. 9, 2023
Focus on Quality Yields Success for Producers in France
Despite a sharp drop in production due to Europe’s prolonged drought, the number of French entries at the World Competition has progressively increased over the years.
Dec. 12, 2023
Production Rebound Still Expected in France After Mixed Harvest
Production could rise to 4,400 tons, though some producers are seeing worse yields than last year.
Aug. 31, 2023
Malta’s New Olive Growers Cooperative Seeks to Professionalize Historic Sector
Ahead of a bumper harvest, the cooperative aims to transform the thousand-year-old sector through investment, education and tourism.
Apr. 25, 2023
Award-Winning Producer Dedicates Accolade to Late Wife
Ivan Pfeiffer says he will rename his olive oil brand for his wife, who suddenly passed away.
Jul. 31, 2023
Turkey Receives PDO for Edremit Olive Oil
Nearly 10 million olive trees fall into the new Protected Designation of Origin-certified region in northwestern Anatolia.