A key finding in a new report by the UC Davis Olive Center was questioned earlier today.
The report stated “10 percent of California olive oil samples labeled as extra virgin olive oil failed to meet the IOC/USDA standards for extra virgin olive oil.” The 10 percent referred to a single sample of Bariani extra virgin olive oil that was found by a lab in Australia to display sensory defects. Extra virgin olive oil, according to IOC and USDA guidelines cannot have such defects.
An Olive Oil Times article on the report pointed out today that, according to the report’s appendix, the Bariani olive oil that failed the sensory testing was bought,
and tested, well after the “best before” date.
None of the other samples tested in the study were past their expiration dates, although a few had no dates at all.
Another finding of the study, namely that 69 percent of imported extra virgin olive oils tested failed to meet IOC and USDA standards was not being challenged.
The age of an olive oil can greatly affect its sensory characteristics and, consequently, how well it scores in an organoleptic analysis. In a recent article expert Paul Vossen, University of California Cooperative Extension farm adviser and senior faculty member pointed out “a fresh olive oil is crisp. It has a lot of zing to it, a lot of complexity and depth to it. Whereas old oils, they’re just kind of greasy and flat.”
Dan Flynn, director of the UC Davis Olive Center, later responded in an email to Olive Oil Times explaining that the laboratory that tested the samples, the Australian Oils Research Laboratory in Wagga Wagga, New South Wales, made a typographical error and the January 2010 date entered as the “best before” date on the sample’s data sheet was actually the bottling date. Flynn provided an enlargement of an image in the report identifying the Bariani sample to support the explanation and the report’s appendix was later corrected.
.
Related Articles
Sep. 14, 2023
Olive Oil Prices Soar on Drought and Poor Harvests, Impacting Consumers Worldwide
Olive oil prices are soaring due to drought and poor harvests in major producing countries with varying impacts in different regions.
Dec. 19, 2023
Olive Center Works to Educate Next Generation of Ag. Pros
The Olea Learn program teaches undergraduates the necessary agronomic and business skills to run an olive farming and olive oil production business.
May. 17, 2023
Global Olive Oil Production Predicted to Rebound
USDA economists project that production will rise in Europe and Tunisia.
Jun. 27, 2023
Jaime Lillo Appointed Olive Council Executive Director
As deputy director, Lillo has emphasized olive oil's role in promoting environmental and social sustainability.
Dec. 12, 2023
Role of Women in Sector Takes Center Stage at World Olive Day
Celebrated at the International Olive Council’s headquarters in Madrid, the event spotlighted the role women play in the olive sector.
Jan. 16, 2024
IOC Leader Focuses on Expanding Cultivation, Fighting Climate Change
The International Olive Council director, Jaime Lillo, says the future of olive oil production lies beyond the Mediterranean.
Aug. 17, 2023
Chemistry Takes Center Stage at Olive Center Course
The workshop is an opportunity to get practical, hands-on experience at a state-of-the-art laboratory
Nov. 1, 2023
Olive Trees Can Help Beat Climate Change
At a three-day conference, the International Olive Council emphasized the role olive farming can play in efforts to reach global net zero emissions.