`Olive Oil Tops E.U. List of Foods at Most Risk of Fraud - Olive Oil Times

Olive Oil Tops E.U. List of Foods at Most Risk of Fraud

Oct. 21, 2013
Julie Butler

Recent News


Olive oil, fish and organic foods are the prod­ucts most prone to food fraud, accord­ing to a draft report of a European Parliament com­mit­tee which also calls for tougher penal­ties.

Committing food fraud in the E.U. is lucra­tive, the chances of get­ting caught are rel­a­tively low, and the num­ber of cases appears to be ris­ing.


And the evi­dence that crim­i­nal orga­ni­za­tions are becom­ing more involved in food fraud is all the more wor­ri­some,” the report also says.

Prepared by the Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety, the report — on the food cri­sis, fraud in the food chain and the con­trol thereof” — fol­lows a four-month inquiry and is open to amend­ment until October 28. The com­mit­tee refer­ral was announced in Parliament on June 10 and came came in the wake of Europe’s horse meat scan­dal.

Fraud risk list based on aca­d­e­mic research, police records and indus­try con­sul­ta­tions

The Committee’s spokes­woman on the report, Holland’s Esther de Lange, said on Friday that it fol­lowed con­sul­ta­tion with all rel­e­vant par­ties, includ­ing pro­duc­ers, traders, retail­ers, con­sumers, sci­en­tists, national author­i­ties, the European Commission, and Europol.

She said she was sur­prised meat was not among the top ten foods most sub­ject to fraud. After olive oil, fish and organic foods come milk, grains, honey and maple syrup, cof­fee and tea, spices (such as saf­fron and chili pow­der), wine, and cer­tain fruit juices.

The list was based on aca­d­e­mic stud­ies (1), police records and indus­try con­sul­ta­tions. The draft report does not say why olive oil came first.

Findings include cross-bor­der fraud hard to penal­ize

Among other find­ings in the report are that:

- the key char­ac­ter­is­tics of food fraud are: 1) non-com­pli­ance with food law and/or mis­lead­ing the con­sumer, 2) which is done inten­tion­ally and 3) for rea­sons of finan­cial gain. Different types of food fraud include adul­ter­ation, sub­sti­tu­tion, tam­per­ing and coun­ter­feit­ing;

- cur­rent E.U. laws largely focus on food safety thus food fraud goes largely unde­tected, espe­cially when there are no pub­lic health or food safety issues;

- recent fraud cases include the mar­ket­ing of ordi­nary flour as organic flour, of bat­tery cage eggs as organic eggs, of road salt as food salt, and of horse­meat as beef, and the use of methanol-con­t­a­m­i­nated alco­hol in spir­its;

- juris­dic­tion issues often pre­vent suc­cess­ful pros­e­cu­tion of fraud­u­lent food busi­ness oper­a­tors oper­at­ing across E.U. bor­ders;

- whis­tle-blow­ers are key in uncov­er­ing food fraud and need sup­port.

Calls for big­ger fines, strate­gic polic­ing

Among the rec­om­men­da­tions are:

- more sys­tem­atic col­lec­tion of data on fraud cases;

- that offi­cial con­trols focus not only on food safety issues, but also on pre­vent­ing fraud;

- a move from an admin­is­tra­tive and vet­eri­nary” approach to a polic­ing one , based on risk-pro­fil­ing and the expe­ri­ence of the Danish Food Administration’s fly­ing squad’ and of the Arma dei Carabinieri and the Guardia di Finanza in Italy;

- a legal onus on food busi­ness oper­a­tors to report food fraud cases;

- sanc­tions of at least dou­ble the amount of the eco­nomic advances sought through the food fraud.

Focus on food safety only allows fraud to thrive

De Lange said that while pub­lic health came first, a one-sided focus on it by the European Commission and the E.U. Member States had allowed other cases of food fraud to pass under the radar.

She said a new def­i­n­i­tion of, and approach, to food fraud was needed.

Only if the coun­tries and the E.U., the gov­ern­ment and indus­try, work together can we make a stand against food fraud,” she said.

Olive Oil Times Video Series

Related Articles

Feedback / Suggestions