What's New is Old Again: The Deep Roots of Today's Olive Oil Trends
What might seem like current trends in the olive oil business aren't so novel at all -- just the latest continuations of stories that began long ago.
The olive oil business has been tumultuous for a long time, with issues such as purity guarantees, tariff reductions, and adulteration of products dating back over a century. Despite the perception of current trends in the industry, many of these issues have been ongoing for years, as seen through historical archives from sources like the New York Times.
The olive oil business might seem at times tumultuous and ever-changing — and it is, with energetic up-and-coming producers, industry infighting over market share and the uproar over less-than-standard products.
But olive oil has been around a very long time, of course, and many of the things we see happening these days in the category turn out to be not so new at all.
Looking back through the archives of the New York Times, the Associated Press and other sources, what might seem like current trends are just the latest continuations of stories that began long ago.
We just thought we’d share some of the more interesting snippets we came across flipping through the last 100 years, or so, of olive oil’s ancient history.
(Some sources require logins to view the original article.)
August 21, 1891
California Producers Band Together
“The convention of olive oil producers, recently assembled (in San Francisco) took a decided stand for pure, home-made olive oil. The convention has now established the very conditions of success — concerted action securing a perfect guarantee of the purity of olive oil produced in San Francisco.”
February 17, 1912
Cal. Growers Denounce Proposed Tariff Reduction
“A proposal to reduce the tariff on olive oil threatens the annihilation of the olive oil industry in California. ‘Don’t permit this infant industry to be strangled as it has never had adequate protection.’ The Olive Growers’ Association of Los Angeles said. ‘If the tariff is reduced, it will compel us to discontinue raising olives.’ ”
April 14, 1914
Italy Ships More than it Makes
“The consul says it would seem that more oil is being sent to the United States as Lucca or Tuscan olive oil than the district produces for export.”
November 25, 1918
Unscrupulous Dealers
“Very little olive oil is now being imported and the domestic olive oil is not sufficient to supply the demand. The abnormally high price of genuine olive oil has tempted unscrupulous dealers to mix cheaper vegetable oils with a little genuine olive oil and to sell the mixture labeled as olive oil.”
August 27, 1919
*Not* Made in Italy
“Shipments of olive oil labeled as having been produced in Italy, but which, in fact, was produced in Spain, have been seized in San Francisco.”
April 23, 1922
Better than Bootlegging
“There is more profit in adulterating olive oil than bootlegging, said the health commissioner. 17 percent of the samples taken last year were adulterated.”
July 15, 1930
40 Percent of California Olive Oils are Substandard
In 1930, the Maryland-based olive oil importer Pompeian Corporation carried out its own study that revealed, “So-called California virgin olive oils” were not from the first pressing. “Over 40 percent of the so-called pure, un-adulterated virgin olive oils are falsely labeled — containing from 25 to 100 percent refined oil,” the company said. (Guess you could call the 2011 Davis report, 81 years later, delayed payback.)
Industrial and Engineering Chemistry
July 22, 1930
Extra Virgin Motor Oil
“Manuel Pinol, a member of the Seville municipal council, motored today from that city to Madrid using olive oil as the only lubricant of his car. The experimenter said he consumed one liter of the oil with excellent results. Olive producers have asked the government to support experiments which they hope will result in extensive use of olive oil for lubrication as a measure toward solving the problem of olive over-production.”
June 2, 1934
Olive Oil Chemists Form Group
“Organization of an international committee of olive oil chemists, which will seek to develop standard methods for the analysis of olive oil was announced here yesterday by W.H. Dickhart, chairman. Included are chemists connected with the olive oil industry in Spain, France and Italy. The committee will try to develop new methods for determining the purity of olive oil.”
June 3, 1936
No Soap for You
“The Senate Today adopted an amendment to eliminate the proposed tax on olive oil. Senator Moore said the tax would destroy soap manufacturing operations that use olive oil.”
August 2, 1937
Olive Oil Group Revived
“Rising world prices, due to the civil war in Spain, have added a new incentive to the adulteration of olive oil by unscrupulous importers and have prompted revival of the Olive Oil Association.”
February 4, 1941
Italian Production Below Average
“Italy’s olive oil crop is below average this critical year. World production is estimated at 7.5 million quintals (827,000 tons).”
May 25, 1941
California Rising
“California has been producing olive oil for twenty years but never better quality or more quantity than this year. The increased demand has brought a rise in prices for domestic oils too and many growers who formerly packed their choicest Mission and Manzanilla olives are now using them to manufacture oil. This year, 900,000 gallons of olive oil were pressed out in California.”
May 13, 1942
Nazi Lubricant
“German engines of war are lubricated with olive oil, indicating that the Nazis are running low on vital raw materials, Eugene Varga, the Soviet’s foremost economist, said in today’s edition of the Communist party newspaper Pravda.”
May 23, 1943
Olive Oil from Peanuts
“Olive Oil from peanuts has been produced successfully at the Southern regional research laboratory of the USDA. Both are wartime substitutes, but will probably carry over into peace for uses where they are either superior or cheaper.”
January 27, 1956
Brooklyn Man Fined $4,000 for ‘Misbranding’
“Joseph Profaci, a Brooklyn olive oil distributor, was fined $4,000 yesterday in federal Court, Brooklyn, for misbranding his product. Two companies that Profaci formerly headed, the Mamma Mia Importing Company, Inc., and the Santuzzo Oil Company, Inc., also were fined a total of $4,000.”
July 18, 1959
Tunisia the World’s Largest Olive Oil Exporter
“Tunisia has emerged during the last three years as the world’s largest exporter of olive oil, and the 1959 season produced a harvest that set a new peak at 135,000 tons.”
April 16, 1989
Light Olive Oil: Product of New Jersey
“Light olive oil was invented by the Bertolli company in this office in Secaucus, N.J.,” said William C. Monroe, president of Bertolli USA. “It’s an American invention.”
Related Articles
Dec. 5, 2025
Archaeologists Uncover Massive Roman Olive Oil Complex in Tunisia
Archaeologists excavating Henchir el-Begar in central Tunisia have uncovered one of the largest olive-oil production complexes of the Roman world, complete with monumental beam presses.
Apr. 22, 2025
Discovery of Ancient Olive Farming in Sicily Challenges Previous Beliefs
Researchers have discovered evidence of ancient olive farming in Sicily, 1,000 years earlier than previously thought, through pollen analysis and historical analysis.
May. 31, 2025
Italian Producers Extend Reign of Excellence at World Competition
Uncompromising farmers, millers and bottlers made Italy the most awarded country at the 2025 NYIOOC for the tenth consecutive year.
Jul. 8, 2025
New Study Suggests Olive Oil May Reduce Breast Cancer Risk
New research in Italy suggests that olive oil consumption may be linked to a reduced risk of estrogen and progesterone-negative breast cancer.
Dec. 15, 2025
Italy’s National Cuisine Inscribed on UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage List
Italy has become the first country to have its entire national cuisine recognized by UNESCO, highlighting Italian cooking as a living heritage rooted in sustainability, diversity and shared traditions.
Feb. 18, 2025
Archaeological Exhibition Explores History of Olive Oil in the Mediterranean
The event, held at the Collège de France, displays archaeological discoveries about the trade and production of olive oil in the Mediterranean.
Jul. 23, 2025
PDO and PGI Tourism Boosts Olive Oil Industry in Italy
Report highlights the growing trend of sustainable tourism in Italy, creating new opportunities for producers and promoting the country's unique regions.
Oct. 9, 2025
Olive Tree Emerges as Symbol of Interconnected Health and Sustainability
A new review led by Yale researchers highlights the olive tree’s unique role in connecting human, animal, and environmental health — a living model of the “One Health” approach to sustainability.