Recent News

Corto Olive, L.P., one of Cal­i­for­ni­a’s lead­ing olive oil pro­duc­ers filed a law­suit today in United States Dis­trict Court for the Cen­tral Dis­trict of Cal­i­for­nia against Gemsa Enter­prises, LLC for what Corto said is a fla­grant com­mod­ity knock-off of its 51 – 49 brand of blended oil.

A lawyer rep­re­sent­ing Corto Olive con­firmed the fil­ing and pro­vided a copy to Olive Oil Times. Gemsa did not imme­di­ately respond to a request for com­ments.

“Gemsa’s attempt to deceive cus­tomers into think­ing they are buy­ing our prod­uct, instead of a com­mod­ity knock-off, is so fla­grant that we had to take action. We are deter­mined to enforce our rights in every instance that a com­peti­tor attempts to steal our intel­lec­tual prop­erty, and we will pro­tect the restau­ra­teurs and food­ser­vice dis­trib­u­tors who count on our trade­mark as the mark of pre­mium olive oil,” said Tom Cor­topassi, senior man­ag­ing part­ner of Corto Olive.

Accord­ing to a press state­ment, Corto sent Gemsa a let­ter in May 2018 demand­ing that it halt the use of the 51 – 49® trade­mark, but Gemsa failed to take cor­rec­tive action. Corto first became aware of Gem­sa’s use of the mark in May of this year.

“Defendant’s 51/49 Mark is not mate­ri­ally dif­fer­ent from Plaintiff’s 51 – 49 Mark, and Defendant’s use of the 51/49 Mark is likely to cause con­fu­sion, mis­take or decep­tion of pur­chasers and poten­tial pur­chasers as to the ori­gin, spon­sor­ship, or approval of the prod­uct,” the fil­ing said.

The pack­ages are remark­ably sim­i­lar, lead­ing Corto to argue that Gemsa intended to cause con­fu­sion: ​“Defendant’s copy­ing and con­tin­ued use of Plaintiff’s intel­lec­tual prop­erty is will­ful, evi­denced by the extent to which Defen­dant has copied not only the 51 – 49 Mark but also the detail of Plaintiff’s 51 – 49 Trade Dress.”

Corto asked the court in its fil­ing to stop Gemsa from sell­ing prod­ucts bear­ing the brand; order a recall and destruc­tion of the asso­ci­ated Gemsa prod­ucts; and pay Corto all mon­e­tary gains from sell­ing the prod­uct, in addi­tion to puni­tive dam­ages and other relief.

• Corto Olive, L.P. v. Gemsa Enter­prises, LLC