Richard and Myrna Meisler have turned a passion project into one of California’s most-awarded extra virgin olive oils.
In the hills west of San Miguel, on California’s Central Coast, sits the picturesque four-hectare farm of the eponymous San Miguel Olive Farm.
Over the years, the husband and wife team of Richard and Myrna Meisler have achieved a legacy of high-quality extra virgin olive oil production by carefully controlling every aspect of the process, from the manual harvest to the milling conditions.
We don’t have high tech to help us, but a good eye to know when to water, when to pick and how to blend.- Richard Meisler, co-owner, San Miguel Olive Farm
The couple say their award-winning olive production is more than a farming operation; it is a passion project.
“Thirty-four years ago, we bought a property in Central California, three hours from where we lived,” co-owner Richard Meisler said. “Seventeen years ago, we planted ten olive trees on that property, just down from where we have lived for 24 years. That was the beginning of quite the adventure.”
See Also:Producer Profiles“Eventually, we ended up with 1,200 Tuscan olive trees on our farm,” he added. “The first oil we produced in 2012 gave us seven gallons (26.5 liters).”
The Meislers entered that oil in local quality contests and received several awards. “We sold out immediately and had to turn away many prospective buyers,” Meisler said.
With this success in hand, they started looking at how to expand. With the help of friends and local producers, the Meislers realized they could plant many more olive trees on their land.
“Myrna had an uncle who kept sending articles about olive trees, encouraging her to plant them on our land,” Meisler said. “She read an article in our newspaper about two local olive growers and contacted them. Soon, we discovered a whole network of helpful people.”
The Mesilers explored local resources to achieve their goals, looking for olive varieties best suited to the growing conditions of their property.
“It was exciting to learn as we went,” Meisler said. “Finding a reputable olive tree nursery north of us, we met the owner, who advised us on choosing the best varieties for our climate, and we ended up with five Tuscan olive varieties,” including Frantoio, Leccino, Maurino, Pendolino and Taggiasca.
Neither of them had a farming background, which did not stop them. They became passionate about growing, learning and producing extra virgin olive oil.
“Having never farmed, we just jumped in without looking back,” Myrna Meisler said. “Digging the holes for the small trees took imagination. But we both worked many days all day, getting the job done.”
Networking with local producers was an ongoing part of success. “We joined an informal gathering of other growers. In this group, we learned about irrigation and the olive fruit fly, pruning, harvesting and so much more,” Richard Meisler added.
The couple takes pride in every aspect of their work. They offer olive farming experiences and educational tours, including tastings. Guided by enthusiasm, they made what they believed was a critical decision to hand harvest with care.
“We made decisions which differed from others but ones we have kept all these years,” Meisler said. “We only hand-harvest, are pesticide-free, farm naturally, and all is done with care. A lot of love has gone into what we do.”
“We don’t have high tech to help us, but a good eye to know when to water, when to pick and how to blend,” he added.
The couple is optimistic about the 2023/34 crop year in San Luis Obispo County, home to many of the country’s most-awarded olive oil producers. The early harvest has already been completed, with the first Olio Nuovo bottled and ready to sell.
“Richard was busy selecting the rows and trees to harvest, and we had people waiting for the Olio Nuovo for almost a year,” Myrna Meisler said. “The 2022 extra virgin olive oil is sold out, and we are producing only 75 bottles of our Olio Nuovo 2023.”
With the early harvest complete, the couple expects to finish off the season at the end of November with two more days of picking before taking the olives to a carefully selected mill for transformation.
After a challenging season in 2023, the Meislers feel much better about their yield this year.
“Last year was not good at all,” Richard Meisler said. “We had a very small crop, yet were still happy to produce exceptional high phenol delicious olive oils.”
Producing olive oil in California is not for the faint at heart. With climate change, economic impacts, and unpredictable conditions, the Meislers continue to take changes in stride.
“The challenges are not bad,” Meisler said with a smile. “The products we need have doubled in price. The easiness has disappeared, and the quality is not the same. Freight has doubled, and the good old ‘taking care of business’ seems unimportant.”
While olive farming was new to the Meislers, entering the NYIOOC World Olive Oil Competition marked another milestone on their olive oil-producing journey.
They have won 19 awards at the NYIOOC since 2018, including three Gold Awards in the 2023 edition of the contest.
“Winning Gold Awards was our goal, especially in this competition. Silver is fine, but it makes you think, ‘how can we win a Gold next year?” Meisler said. “We did and won big time.”
Along with the satisfaction of knowing that they are keeping quality consistent, Myrna Mesiler said the awards provide unique commercial value, especially for small producers competing in a crowded market.
“The gold stickers on our bottles have been a selling point, and they are very important for high-quality extra virgin olive oil,” she added.
The Meislers have placed all of their quality awards – about 160 in total – along the walls of their tasting room. The accolades serve as a reminder to keep improving and working hard. They are also memories of great moments and all the new people they have met along the way.
“Each award is a stepping stone for our business. Success takes time and perseverance,” Meisler concluded. “We like to say, ‘Steady Eddie.’ And it reminds us to keep on going.”
More articles on: California olive oil, NYIOOC World, NYIOOC World 2023
Jun. 5, 2023
Goya Spain GM Says the Global Olive Oil Sector Potential Lies with Young Consumers
Antonio Carrasco believes olive oil brands must define themselves through quality while communicating these values to young people.
Jul. 5, 2023
Researchers in Andalusia Develop AI Tool to Improve Irrigation Efficiency
Using climatic data and powerful neural networks, researchers haver developed a tool that allows farmers to determine irrigation requirements a week in advance.
Aug. 2, 2023
Education Vital to Success of Turkey’s Olive Oil Sector, Award-Winning Producer Says
After winning 10 awards at the 2023 NYIOOC World Olive Oil Competition, the producers behind Oliva Malia are keen to share the secrets of their success.
Jun. 21, 2023
Andalusian Producers Achieve Outstanding Quality After Disastrous Harvest
After the smallest harvest in more than a decade, producers in Spain earned their fourth-highest award count at the World Olive Oil Competition.
Apr. 3, 2024
Nurseries in Spain Are Running Low on Olive Tree Seedlings
High olive oil prices at origin, interest from private equity and farmers seeking to shift away from more water-intensive crops are fueling the shortages.
Sep. 25, 2023
Olive Farmers in Puglia Face Catastrophic Harvest After Autumn Storms
The damage to the southern Italian region’s olive trees is expected to drive up prices in the short term and lower production in future harvests.
Apr. 16, 2024
Tuscan Producer Adapts to a Changing Olive Oil Landscape
Fattoria di Volmiano embraces new ways to produce high-quality extra virgin olive oil.
Apr. 9, 2024
Slovenian Producers Celebrate Award-Winning Finish to Challenging Harvest
While Slovenia's production fell 20 percent below average, two producers overcame inclement weather and pests to produce award-winning extra virgin olive oil.